X-Men, not X-Women (Caitlin Henshaw)

They were the heroes of your childhood. The team of superheroes you could actually see yourself being a part of. They were the X-Men, a team of mutant men and women each born with a unique set of superpowers. This year, Marvel is bringing them back in a bold new way.

In their latest incarnation, creators Brian Wood and Oliver Coipel have put together an all female team of X-Men to fight off an impending invasion of alien forces. Wood and Coipel are A-List creators in the comic book world and have managed to generate a lot of buzz for their new pet project.

Marvel doesn’t have the best track record when it comes to producing female heroes, often ignoring them or drawing them like soft-core porn stars. But X-Men has been one of the few avenues where Marvel has managed to get it right. They’ve created a slew of powerful, strong willed heroines and are now taking advantage of that with this new series.

The cover art alone speaks volumes of Wood and Coipel’s enlightened approach. Rather than falling back on anatomically incorrect cleavage shots (that female heroes are subjected to far too often), Wood and Coipel’s cover looks like a poster for an all girl rock band. Of course, this doesn’t necessarily mean the series itself will be good, but in the comic book world the cover can actually say quite a bit about what’s inside a book’s pages.

Before the first issue has even been released though, there has been an online push by some fans to change the title of the series. As of right now the series is simply being called X-Men, but some fans have been suggested that an all female team needs its own title. X-Women and XX were two of the main suggestions tweeted to creator Brian Wood. Thankfully, Wood’s responses to these tweets show why he’s exactly the right person to be writing this series.

“…Over my dead body,” he tweeted, “They’re X-Men. Always have been.”

He’s quite right too. Storm, Rouge and Jubilee, the leading members of this new X-Men series, have all been long time members of the X-Men team. From the very beginning, X-Men has never been a team of just men. It’s what makes the series so appealing. Anyone can be a mutant and anyone can be hero (or villain if that’s your thing).

The men in X-Men has always been a reference to the not-so-politically-correct term mankind and the fact mutants stand apart from them. The title has never been a reference to gender of its team members, but the fact that we’re having this debate now highlights an unfortunate tendency of today’s post-feminist society.

In the patriarchal days of past, women often banded together as a way of empowering themselves against female oppression. There was strength in numbers and all girl groups were a means of rebelling against the male dominated system that refused to admit them. The point of declaring to the world we are women though was not to set women apart. Feminism at its core has always been about equality. For the most part, North American society has managed to achieve that goal, at least in a legal sense. Society always takes a bit more time to catch up though as this X-Women debate has shown.

It’s funny too because this desire to label the team X-Women doesn’t actually spawn from some sexist desire to set women apart. At the heart of it, I would chalk this up to humanity’s obsessive need to group and label everything. It’s understandable too. Labels make things easier for us. They allow us to attach traits to people and make assumptions without actually having to get to know a person. When people see a group of super powered women they want to call them a group of women, rather than just a group. The label women makes things more specific and easier for our brains to understand.

The problem though is that if this were a group of all super powered men, we wouldn’t feel the same need to label them so. It’s the backlash we feel of a once male dominated society. Men are still considered the norm. Women are something different, a deviation from the norm. It doesn’t matter that mentally, physically and legally women can do just about anything men can do. Nor does it matter that all people, male or female, are far more complicated than their gender label implies. We still feel this innate desire to put them in a neat little box. Thus, spawns our need to label this new X-Team as X-Women.

Lucky for us, Brian Wood understands that a character is more than just their gender. In an interview with Wired magazine he stated, “The key to writing good female characters is simply to try to understand them on a human level first, and then consider the character from a perspective of gender.”

It’s sad that I’m so shocked to hear these words coming out of the mouth of a man. Thinking of them as a person first? Considering their brains before their breasts? By God, what a revolutionary thought! But hearing it gives me hope for both humanity and the future of the Marvel franchise. At the end of the day, all anyone wants is to be seen for what they are: people. In the land of capes and heroes, that goes double. This new team X-Men may be women, but they’re heroes first.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *